Batista (Civilian) - In Jericho's RTWM, win against Kofi, Henry, and Batista in Week 8.
Chris Jericho (Civilian) - In Jericho's RTWM, talk to Stephanie McMahon in the GM's office, then win Week 1's Match Of The Week, while executing at least one finisher and not taking heavy damage.
Christian (Civilian) - In Christian's RTWM, defeat Tyson Kidd or William Regal in a Royal Rumble side story match.
Christian (Conquistador) - Initiate the Week 4 Challenge in Rey Mysterio's RTWM.
CM Punk (T-Shirt) - Purchase "ALL Axxess" from the WWE Shop.
Edge (Civilian) - In Christian's RTWM, defeat Big Show in a locker room area during the "Elimination Chamber".
Jack Swagger (Civilian) - In Rey Mysterio's RTWM, partner with Jack Swagger during Week 3, and win the Match Of The Week as Jack Swagger.
John Cena (Entrance/Civilian) - In Cena's RTWM, win the Week 8 Challenge against Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase.
Masked Kane Attire - Win against Masked Kane in the "Vs. Undertaker RTWM".
MVP (Civilian) - In Cena's RTWM, win both the Week 5 and Week 7 Tag Team Challenge Match against R-Truth and Mike Knox.
Randy Orton (Ref attire) - In Cena's RTWM, defeat Randy Orton in the WrestleMania Match Of The Week during the Lost Week 9 timeline.
Randy Orton (Suit) - In Cena's RTWM, defeat Randy Orton in the WrestleMania Match Of The Week during the Won Week 9 timeline.
Randy Orton (T-Shirt) - In Cena's RTWM, defeat Randy Orton in under 3 minutes during the Week 12 "I Quit" match in the Lost Week 9 timeline.
Rey Mysterio (Civilian) - In Rey Mysterio's RTWM, eliminate Evan Bourne in the Royal Rumble and win the Royal Rumble.
Rey Mysterio (Evil) and Entrance Scene - Successfully complete Rey Mysterio's RTWM with Rey set to "Evil".
Shawn Michaels (Civilian) - Purchase "ALL Axxess" at the WWE Shop.
Ted DiBiase (T-Shirt) - In Cena's RTWM, defeat Ted DiBiase to win the Week 11 Tag Team Challenge against Ted DiBiase and Cody Rhodes.
Todo Americano - In Rey Mysterio's RTWM, perform a finisher on Todo Americano while playing as Evan Bourne in Week 12.
Triple H (Civilian) - In Jericho's RTWM, escape to the parking lot without losing to Triple H in Week 6.
Vince McMahon (Suit) - In Jericho's RTWM, win the WWE Championship against Triple H at WrestleMania XXVI.